Discussion on Artificial Intelligence in Music Stirs Up Ukrainian Talent Show
A contestant's performance on a vocal show using a song generated by a neural network sparked a fierce debate among star coaches regarding the ethics of AI in art.
Photo: TSN
Key points
- Contestant performs an AI-generated song on a talent show.
- Conflict between Artem Pivovarov and Natalia Mogilevskaya.
- Tina Karol's stance on supporting human authors.
During the broadcast of the popular vocal show 'Holos Krayiny-14', a contestant's performance triggered a lively professional discussion. A 47-year-old vocal coach from Kharkiv, Oksana Petrova, performed a song titled 'Red Poppy' on stage. However, her appearance was remembered by the audience not only for her vocal abilities, but also because the song she chose was generated using artificial intelligence.
Star Coaches Debate AI Ethics
Such a repertoire drew sharp opposition from singer and mentor Artem Pivovarov. The artist emotionally spoke out against popularizing such content, noting that in today's realities it is important to support living authors rather than algorithms. In his opinion, tolerating such trends is misguided, especially against the backdrop of European practices restricting such music on streaming platforms.
At the same time, another show coach, Natalia Mogilevskaya, came to the contestant's defense. She believes that performing such a composition demonstrates the courage and modernity of the participant who is willing to experiment. Mogilevskaya suggested that the vocalist chose her repertoire with her heart, trying to add human warmth to a technological product.
Sing what a human writes. Especially since there are so many authors in Ukraine!
Tina Karol also joined the discussion, supporting Pivovarov's stance. She emphasized that tracks created by artificial intelligence are often technically unsuited for full human performance. According to Karol, the Ukrainian music industry has plenty of talented authors whose works much better reveal a vocalist's potential.
Source TSN — tsn.ua/glamur/pyvovarov-rozliutyvsia-cherez-vykonanu-uchasnytseiu-holos… ↗
Read next
Rescue operation in Kyiv region: 7-year-old boy survived 14 hours under rubble
In Dymer, rescuers pulled a child from the ruins of a residential building destroyed by a Russian drone. Search operations continue, as the fate of ten people remains unk…
Preparing for Winter: How to Protect Your Home from Rodents
As temperatures drop, residents of Kiliia should focus on sealing their homes to prevent rodent infestations.
👥SocietyKate Middleton presents a documentary on her cancer journey
The Princess of Wales has released a documentary titled 'Heal', offering an honest look at her battle with cancer and the recovery process.
🏙️CityUp to 3.5 Queues of Blackouts: Ukraine Introduces Round-the-Clock Power Outage Schedules
On November 23, round-the-clock scheduled power outages of 1 to 3.5 queues will take effect across several Ukrainian regions following Russian attacks on the energy grid.
Power grid under pressure: what to expect from electricity blackout schedules
On Monday, November 23, hourly power outage schedules ranging from 1 to 3.5 queues will be in effect across Ukraine due to the aftermath of attacks.
AfD co-leader calls for mass deportation of foreigners, including Ukrainians
Tino Chrupalla, co-chair of the Alternative for Germany party, has proposed the return of millions of migrants once conditions in their home countries improve.